A "Big Government" Experiment Nearly a Thousand Years Ago
The core of Wang Anshi’s reforms was to have the state step more actively into the economy: lending money to farmers, having officials regulate prices, unifying collection and distribution. The idea sounds familiar today, but set nearly a thousand years ago it was so far ahead that his contemporaries could hardly accept it. Conservatives like Sima Guang fiercely opposed it, holding that the state was competing with the people for profit and disrupting order. The reforms were enacted and then repealed amid controversy and resistance, and ultimately failed — yet the question they left behind is argued to this day: should the hand of the state manage the economy at all, and can it manage it well?